상세 정보

underline
Metadata Downloads : dc(xml) or Excel
Cited 0 time in scopus ci

Title 

The importance of using realistic evolutionary models for retrodicting proteomes

Authors 

Kyung Mo KimA NasirG Caetano-Anolles

Publisher 

Elsevier

Issue Date 

2014

Citation 

Biochimie, vol. 99, no. 1, pp. 129-137

Keywords 

EvolutionFold superfamilyPhylogeneticsSuperkingdomsTree of life

Abstract 

The reconstruction of phylogenetic trees from molecular data requires selecting models of molecular evolution that adequately describe known processes of change. Operationally, these models optimize molecular changes along branches of the trees. The underlying processes must be realistic and must comply with well-supported biological assumptions. In a recent paper, a new model of proteome evolution that penalizes growth of the protein world provides an 'upside down' phylogeny and identifies a very complex ancestor of diversified life. Here we show that the model is phylogenetically self-inconsistent and at odds with considerable background knowledge, including the scale-free property of domain networks, genomic scaling laws, and the principle of continuity that supports the tenets of ideographic analysis and evolutionary thinking. While technical and conceptual limitations invalidate the main conclusions of the study, including the existence of bottlenecks in protein evolution caused by planetary cataclysms, we use the example to highlight the complexities and pitfalls of retrodiction in phylogenetic and phylogenomic analyses and reexamine the framework of ideographic exploration that is used in scientific inquiry.

ISSN 

0300-9084

Link 

http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.biochi.2013.11.019

Appears in Collections

1. Journal Articles > Journal Articles

Registered Date

2019-05-02


There are no files associated with this item.
qrcode

FusionCharts.
DSpace Software Coptright(c) 2010 MIT and Hewleft-Packard  /  KRIBB-REPOSITORY ( Email:jakim@kribb.re.kr)